Recently a good friend commented in her del.icio.us feed and made the following bold statement regarding an article about breastfeeding:
Man, you can’t trust ANY study you read nowadays! Eggs are bad, eggs are good, wine is bad, wine is good. I just don’t know anymore.
I think it’s important for the public to know the truth about these shocking claims. We’ve got science to back us up here; everybody who follows the field and knows anything about anything agrees: Wine is good.
This comes on good authority from any number of people. There is more supporting evidence for this than there is for any other proposition in the history of man. Using rigorously sound mathematical, logical and entomological methods, I will prove it to you.
First, it is delicious. What else needs be said? Each different variety is more yummy than the next1. If you disagree, you are wrong. It’s as simple as that. You can demonstrate this to yourself using the scientific method. Hypothesis: wine is yummy. Your test: drink a bottle of wine. After the test, you will find the hypothesis verified. If you did not enjoy the wine, your testing methods were incorrect. Try again.
Next, there are many different kinds of wine. As the point most open to debate, this is often called out by wrongheaded wine detractors. There are, they say, very few varieties of wine, sometimes boiling it down to just “red” and “white.” I’m here to tell you that there is also pink and deeper shades of burgundy that the simple moniker “red” fail to properly capture.
Third, it is medically beneficial. Any ailment can be made to seem unimportant with the proper application of wine. As perception is reality, this is proof positive. Above and beyond this logical slam dunk there is more supporting anecdotal evidence — which is the best kind of evidence — than any one proposition needs. I’ve heard at least five stories in which doctors recommended a glass of wine with dinner, and probably seven where a sommelier did the same. That’s twelve members of highly respected fields. You can’t argue with that.
Fourth: Etc.
There are people out there who will disagree. Some of these people have been awarded degrees from the nation’s finest medical schools. I am sorry to say that they are all wrong, no matter what their reasoning. Unless they can soundly refute points one through four above — and they can’t — their opinion carries no water. I hope that after all of this mercilessly insightful logic you agree with me, because wine is in fact good. You can take that to the bank.
1. Order depending on taste, of course.