So, Amazon has its very own MP3 store now. I’m generally happy with iTunes, but Amazon claims to be cheaper and free of DRM, so I gave it a go.
Finding albums/tracks to buy works pretty well the same way that finding CD’s works on Amazon. If you’re familiar with that, it’s a no brainer.
A considerable bummer is that Amazon doesn’t currently link the reviews of CD’s to their MP3 counterparts. There’s the “Also available in CD Format” link that will give you as much, but that’s a whole lot of clicking to do. Amazon really should make this happen on their own. (They already do for books between hardback/paperback/audio book.)
One thing that did catch my eye was price. Isn’t Amazon claiming to be cheaper than iTMS? Almost $2/track doesn’t exactly strike me as cheaper. A quick trip over to iTunes cleared things up for me.
So, track for track:
- Autumn Leaves: $1.94 on Amazon, Unavailable individually on iTunes
- Love For Sale: $1.94 on Amazon, Unavailable individually on iTunes
- Somethin’ Else: $1.94 on Amazon, Unavailable individually on iTunes
- One For Daddy-O: $1.94 on Amazon, Unavailable individually on iTunes
- Dancing In The Dark: $0.89 on Amazon, $0.99 on iTunes
- Bangoon: $0.89 on Amazon, $0.99 on iTunes
Full album: $8.99 on Amazon, $9.99 on iTunes
As iTunes selection is said to be three (or is it six?) times larger than Amazon’s, I’m sure there are examples to be found of things working out the other way around, but this at least explains the rather high price tag on some of the files.
There are handy links to download individual tracks and entire albums. If you’re going to download an entire album, you have to use their downloader application.
The installation is painless enough. You download a disk image file, open it up, double click on the installer and you’re done.
Why it has an installer application as opposed to just dragging the app bundle to the Applications folder is beyond me. I’m sure the conspiracy theorists out there will chalk it up to spyware or similar, but Gruber didn’t find anything immediately amiss after the install, so I’m comfortable enough with it.

When you buy an album, Amazon gives you a “.amz” file that you feed to their downloader. The browser should open it automagically for you in the downloader application. I saved it to the desktop such that I could take this lovely screen shot for you:
One odd thing I noticed is that as soon as you fire up the downloader application, it erases or at least moves the .amz file. Here’s to hoping that it deals with failures or being shut down gracefully. I’d hate to think that you have to finish your download before you stop the app.
The downloader itself is a pretty pedestrian little application. This is probably for the best, though. If all you’re doing is downloading some files, flashy is a bad thing.
A nice touch at the end of the process is that the downloader automatically imports your album in to iTunes. (I’m not sure how this would work for individual tracks. Presumably you’d have to do it yourself.)
So far the process has been pretty simple. Let’s assume away installing the downloader, because you only have to do that once. To download an album on Amazon, you have to do the following:
- Find the album on the site.
- Click on “buy”
- Download the .AMZ file
- Run the downloader application
There are various “are you sure you want to buy this?” steps thrown in, but they can be skipped on subsequent purchases if you want to.
To accomplish the same thing with iTunes, you have to:
- Find the album on iTunes
- Cilck on “buy”
And you’re done.
Clearly iTunes is easier, but Amazon is close enough (especially considering that steps 3 and 4 could be condensed in to one step) that the better price and lack of DRM sells me on the service. (I don’t say this lightly, as I spend a lot of time every week making computers behave correctly and would rather not have to put any effort in to doing the same for software that I’m not paid to write.) I think that from now on if I’m going to buy an album online I’ll definitely check to see if Amazon has it before I buy on iTunes.
Oh, one last thing: Somethin’ Else is a great album. The five star rating that it has on both iTunes and Amazon (on the page for the CD) is well deserved.